Koran only Islam II: Pray to Sina!!

FFI published a previous posting on a sequence of emails with a Koran-only Muslimah. The following is a copy of the last email we received from her, along with the editor’s analysis. The editor decided not to continue correspondence with this lady for reasons that will become apparent while reading her email and the editor’s analysis of her email

Here is her latest email

Well, I guess we well have to start praying to Dr. Ali Sina, and instead of Quraan we will read all Ali Sina’s books for religious guidance

Oh also as your website dictates we will abandon religion altogether and follow our own lust.

You offer much criticism but ZERO alternatives.

Everyone is born a Muslim.  We had no control over our coming and we definitely cannot stop our demise.  The meaning of Muslim is one that submits to the will of Allah.

You’re so cocky stop your own death.  Better yet, kill yourself and prove that there is no god and come back with pictures or some kind of proof.

You want proof, well I should have caught you sooner, you would have seen the crescent moon and the star in the sky during this holy month of Ramadan.

Next time you are up at sunrise or right before sunset notice the Direction the birds are facing while they are chirping (making salat).

Allah says in Quraan ALL of creation worships him.  Only man, was given the test of free will to choose not too.

I choose to worship Allah.  We will all know the truth on judgment day.  I will take my chances with faith.  You take your chances with your learned s cholars and their books.

What man begins a book,” In the name of Allah most gracious most merciful”?  As arrogant as you have proven man to be, why give credit to someone other than yourself? You have definitely gone out of your way to give different men’s opinions and books as references as more relevant.

I put my trust in Allah, period, stop.

You are spreading your jargon of hate well you just met someone that you cannot nor will not agree with or follow your line of thinking and guess what there are millions of those like me.

Islam teaches us that we as individuals are responsible for our worship.  I do not need a mosque to worship Allah I know when I have to make salat, fast during Ramadan, give charity nor do I need help reading or understanding my Quran..  Allah promised Muslims that we will be increased in knowledge and wisdom and that the Quraan is complete..

Obviously you are still looking for your guru!

You must remember one small thing, Allah makes Muslims.  We do not solicit people to become Muslims,anyone that does is not following Quraan.  Allah says he guides, we are to concern ourselves only with the believers.

It is clear you are a non-believer and I doubt if you have ever been a Muslim.  As Allah says for the disbelievers, he puts blinders on your eyes and deafness in your ears, you are not allowed to understand Quraan.  While I on the other hand weep at hearing the words of Allah, it is clear your heart is cold and Allah refuses to guide you.

I will not waste no more of my time with you.  The devil has succeeded with you.  Satan asked Allah why he cursed him, when man will NOT worship him and shed blood.  Unfortunatly Satan was right, you are a prime example. And like Satan said he is taking a whole bunch of Adam’s children with him to hell.

Find someone you can mesmerize with you hypocrisy I am NOT the one.

Peace Out.

Oh Allah protect me from the disbelieving folks.

Editor’s Analysis

I have to admit that this is one of the most idiotic emails we ever received. I will quote verbatim from the above email:

Quote 1
 “Well, I guess we well have to start praying to Dr. Ali Sina, and instead of Quraan we will read all Ali Sina’s books for religious guidance”

The above quote is irrelevant to any of the previous emails to this lady. We suggested to her to read Sina’s challenge. We do that to many people we receive emails from. We walk shoulder to shoulder with our brother Sina. We have a great respect for him. This does not by any means imply that we agree with everything he says. In fact we don’t. But, as a matter of fact, Ali is correct in his accusations to Muhammad in the “Challenge”. When someone is right, the honorable thing to do is to say “Yes he is right”. Trying to belittle our accusations to Muhammad and Islam by saying we should regard Sina and his books as holy is immaterial and unrelated to the issue at hand.

Quote 2
 
 “Oh also as your website dictates we will abandon religion altogether and follow our own lust”

The above quote about FFI site is mistaken. FFI is not against Faith. It is against Hate. FFI does not ask people to abandon religion. In fact, many apostates become believers in other religions. The Rifqa Bary story is one example of that. She left Islam in favor of a God of love and forgiveness. We, at FFI do not see anything wrong with leaving Islam and believing in a different religion. Our main concern is to make people see how Evil Islam is. Once they see that, they will leave Islam. What kind of belief system they chose after that is up to the individual. Also, abandoning religion does not mean that a person will follow his/her own lust. There is a golden rule that applies to everyone: “Treat others as you want to be treated”. This is a universal moral compass that all humans should abide by.

Quote 3
 
 “You offer much criticism but ZERO alternatives.”

This is also incorrect. Other religions are an alternative to Islam. Atheism is another, and so is agnosticism.

Quote 4
 
 “Everyone is born a Muslim.”

This is utter nonsense. I do not know of any child who was born and proceeded to tell other humans around that he/she is a Muslim. In fact, when you go to isolated islands and see how those people in the Island lived, you will see that those people are no Muslims, not by a long shot. In fact, some of them value Pigs to a high degree. What kind of Muslims are those. Well, lets call them “Pigs only Muslims”!

This editor will stop here. This lady’s email is rich with invalid arguments/reasoning and mistaken assumptions. I leave it to the readers to analyze her many mistakes. Pretty much, there almost is not a line in her email that its falsity cannot be shown. This is why I have decided that continuing our email correspondence with her won’t serve any purpose. trying to show the errors of someone who does not have any idea about what good resoning is does not give us any glory. We are not here to put down people, but to try to have a constructive dialogue with those who are willing and able to do so. 

Source: http://www.faithfreedom.org/2009/09/15/koran-only-islam-ii-pray-to-sina/

IHS